Capital asset pricing model, arbitrage pricing theory and portfolio management vinod kothari the capital asset pricing model capm is great in terms of its understanding of risk decomposition of risk into securityspecific risk and market risk. This lecture covers the basics of the capital asset pricing model and looks into its derivation. What are the difference and similarities between capm and. The big difference between apt and capm is that capm only looks at the asset in comparison to market changes, whereas apt looks at multiple factors. Index terms capital asset pricing model, arbitrage pricing theory,mean absolut deviation, jakarta islamic index. Assumptions individual investors are price takers singleperiod investment horizon investments are limited to traded financial assets no taxes, and transaction costs 3. The capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing theory. This distinction yields a valuation formula involving only the essential risk. Apt arbitrage pricing theory and capmcapital asset pricing model part i apt arbitrage pricing theory and capmcapital asset pricing model alike are methods applied in the assessment of any given investments expected returns and risks going in tandem. Pdf the capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage.
Capital asset pricing model capm is a model of the relationship. Capm relies on the historical data while apt is futuristic. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing model. Sep 12, 2015 arbitrage pricing theory apt is a general theory of asset pricing that holds that the expected return of a financial asset. Capital asset pricing model capm and arbitrage pricing theory apt have been a major challenge for economic theorists and practitioners for decades. The capitalassetpricing model and arbitrage pricing theory. Arbitrage pricing theory, often referred to as apt, was developed in the 1970s by stephen ross. Practical applications of arbitrage pricing theory are as follows. Fama outlined several important theoretical differences between a market dominated. Arbitrage pricing theory apt and multifactor models. The model postulates that the equilibrium rates of return on all risky assets are a linear function of. Return on assets roa is a type of return on investment roi metric that measures the profitability of a business in relation to its total assets.
Before we discuss the capm, it would be important to understand risk of portfolios. The basic difference between apt and capm is in the way systematic investment risk is defined. Arbitrage pricing theory apt is an alternate version of the capital asset pricing model capm. Portfolio theory and asset pricing models capital asset pricing model capm efficient frontier capital market line cml security slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Pdf the capitalassetpricing model and arbitrage pricing theory. The capital asset pricing model is an elegant theory with profound implications for asset pricing and investor behavior. When implemented correctly, it is the practice of being able to take a positive and. In both, formulas are used in the determination of the required rate of return for a. It helps in understanding the prices of assets in any international market as it easily describes the price where a mispriced asset is expected to be.
The capitalassetpricing model and arbitrage pricing. Pdf the arbitrage pricing theory approach to strategic. A major alternative to the capital asset pricing model capm is arbitrage pricing theory apt proposed by ross in 1976. The apt is superior to capm in many ways because it separates the risk factors, whereas capm combined all of the risk factors into a single market beta. This theory, like capm, provides investors with an estimated required rate of return on risky securities. Based on intuitively sensible ideas, it is an alluring new concept. This theory, like capm provides investors with estimated required rate of return on risky securities.
Apt stands for arbitrage pricing theory that has become very popular among investors because of its ability to make a fair assessment of pricing of different stocks. Arbitrage pricing theory apt is a general theory of asset pricing that holds that the expected return of a financial asset. The comparative result shows that there is no significant difference between the accuracy of capm and apt methods in estimating the stock return of the company in jakarta islamic index. The capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing theory apt help project the expected rate of return relative to risk, but they consider different variables. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory can both be used to estimate a theoretical rate of return on an asset. Comparing the arbitrage pricing theory and the capital. Study portfolio theory and the capital asset pricing model flashcards from dominique higginss class online, or in brainscapes iphone or android app. Furthermore, we exhibit the practical relevance and assumptions of these models.
Apt considers risk premium basis specified set of factors in addition to the correlation of the price of asset with expected excess return on market portfolio. Nov 16, 2018 arbitrage pricing theory uses the concept of arbitrage to define equilibrium, does not require the existence of market portfolios, and requires fewer assumptions than the capital asset pricing model capm model and more reasonable. Arbitrage pricing theory understanding how apt works. Empirical factor pricing models arbitrage pricing theory apt factors.
Apt considers risk premium basis specified set of factors in addition to the correlation of the price of the asset with expected excess return on the market portfolio. This paper aimed to test the validity of capital asset pricing model. The capm in comparison to the tfm was only dependent on beta. Introduction nvestments can be made both on real and financial. The capitalassetpricing model and arbitrage pricing theory pnas. On the other hand, the factor used in the capm is the difference. Analysis and accuracy level comparison between capital asset pricing model capm and arbitrage pricing theory apt in determining the expected return. Capm considers only single factor while apt considers multifactors. The capital asset pricing model and arbitrage pricing theory. What are the practical applications of arbitrage pricing theory. The capm method while simpler than the atp method takes into consideration the factor of time and does not get too wrapped up over the systematic risk factors that sometimes we can not control. Like the capital asset pricing model, the arbitrage pricing theory assumes. Since its introduction by ross, it has been discussed, evaluated, and tested. Comparing the arbitrage pricing theory and the capital asset.
Further, we explore the arbitrage pricing model with datadriven examples provided using the famamacbeth regressions. Its formal statement entails the following notation. Capm simultaneously simplified markowitzs modern portfolio theory mpt, made it more practical and introduced the idea of specific and systematic risk. Capm is simple and easy to calculate while apt is c. Analysis and accuracy level comparison between capital. Apt is an interesting alternative to the capm and mpt. Arbitrage pricing an overview sciencedirect topics. Espen eckbo 2011 basic assumptions the capm assumes homogeneous expectations and meanexpectations and meanvariance variance preferences. Arbitrage pricing theory is a general theory of asset pricing.
Hedge fund xyz had an average annualized return of 12. Pdf capital asset pricing model capm and arbitrage pricing. It was developed by economist stephen ross in the 1970s. Arbitrage pricing theory, apt introduction t he apt is one of the most important asset pricing theories taught in finance courses, second only to the capital asset pricing model. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory math. Pdf capital asset pricing model versus arbitrage pricing. Apt is often viewed as an alternative to the capital asset pricing model capm. In finance, the apt is a general theory of property pricing that believes that the expected return of financial assets can model as a linear function of various factors or theoretical. Both of them are based on the efficient market hypothesis, and are part of the modern portfolio theory. What are the practical applications of arbitrage pricing. The capital assets pricing model was autonomously and simultaneously developed by william sharpe, jan mossin, and john litner. The model identifies the market portfolio as the only risk factor the apt makes no assumption about. The arbitrage pricing theory approach to strategic portfolio planning article pdf available in financial analysts journal 511.
The arbitrage pricing theory states that systematic risk is of multidimensional character and is therefore dependent on different economic risk factors 55. Apt stands for arbitrage pricing theory that has become very popular among investors because of its ability to. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing. Difference between capm and apt compare the difference.
Apr 15, 1997 in the capitalassetpricing model capm. Difference between short and longterm interest rate. In this paper, i will explain some of the advantages and disadvantages of the capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing theory apt. Theory, advantages, and disadvantages the capital asset pricing model relevant to acca qualification paper f9 capm formula the linear relationship between the return required on an investment whether in stock market securities or in business operations and its systematic risk is represented by the capm formula, which is given in the. Jun 16, 2014 arbitrage pricing theory and multifactor models of risk and return. Before we try to find out the differences between apt and capm, let us take a closer look at the two theories.
The sharpe 1964, lintner 1965 and black 1972 capital asset pricing model capm is considered one of the foundational contributions to the practice of finance. The cost of equity is defined as the expected return on an assets common stock in capital markets witmer and zorn, 2007. Capital asset pricing andarbitrage pricing theory prof. Arbitrage pricing theory apt is an asset pricing model which builds upon the capital asset pricing model capm but defines expected return on a security as a linear sum of several systematic risk premia instead of a single market risk premium. Jun 27, 2012 apt and capm compared apt applies to well diversified portfolios and not necessarily to individual stocks with apt it is possible for some individual stocks to be mispriced not lie on the sml apt is more general in that it gets to an expected return and beta relationship without the assumption of the market portfolio apt can be. Alex shapiro 1 lecture notes 9 the capital asset pricing model capm i. Share valuations are a must for every investor as well as financial expert.
Pdf we present a model of a financial market in which naive diversification, based. Capital asset pricing model, arbitrage pricing theory and. Chapter 7 slides share and discover knowledge on linkedin. May 27, 2011 capm and apt are two such valuation tools. Comparison of the capm, the famafrench three factor model. This work is dedicated to the study of the capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage. Whereas mpt has arbitrary correlation between all investments, capm, in its basic form, only links investments via the market as a whole. The famafrench threefactormodel tfm is based on the arbitrage pricing theory apt and is one of the most famous models.
It is considered to be an alternative to the capital asset pricing model as a method to explain the returns of portfolios or assets. There are inherent risks in holding any asset, and the capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing model apm are both ways of calculating the cost of an asset and the rate of return which can be expected based on the risk level inherent in the asset. Arbitrage pricing theory and multifactor models of risk and return. Chapter 7 capital asset pricing and arbitrage pricing theory. Capm advocates a single, marketwide risk factor for capm while apt considers several factors which capture marketwide risks. Are practitioners and academics, therefore, moving away from capm. Analysis and accuracy level comparison between capital asset. What are the difference and similarities between capm and apt. The apt is a substitute for the capital asset pricing model capm in that both assert a linear relation between assets expected returns and their covariance.
The arbitrage pricing theory apt was developed by stephen ross. Arbitrage pricing theory apt is an alternative to the capital asset pricing model capm for explaining returns of assets or portfolios. We examine the tradeoff between risk and return in real world applications founded on the premises behind the capm. Pdf capital asset pricing model versus arbitrage pricing theory. Capm is a wellknown and accepted single factor model, after four decades. Arbitrage pricing theory assumptions explained hrf.
The arbitrage theory of capital asset pricing was developed by ross 9, 10, 1 l as an alternative to the meanvariance capital asset pricing model capm, whose main conclusion is that the market portfolio is mean variance efficient. The arbitrage pricing theory apt is a theory of asset pricing that holds that an assets returns can be forecasted with the linear relationship of an assets expected returns and the macroeconomic factors that affect the assets risk. While there are investors who are expecting certain rate for their investment in shares in a company, there are lenders and equity holders in a company who also expect dec. Comparing the arbitrage pricing theory and the capital asset pricing model there are inherent risks in holding any asset, and the capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing model apm are both ways of calculating the cost of an asset and the rate of return which can be expected based on the risk level inherent in the asset. Arbitrage pricing theory apt is an alternate version of capital asset pricing capm model. Comparing the arbitrage pricing theory and the capital asset pricing model. January 1990 june 2001 is weak, and the capital asset pricing model. The capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing theory apt have emerged as two models that have tried to scientifically measure the potential for assets to generate a return or a loss. In finance, the capital asset pricing model capm is a model used to determine a theoretically appropriate required rate of return of an asset, to make decisions about adding assets to a welldiversified portfolio. While the capm is a singlefactor model, apt allows for multifactor models to describe risk and return relationship of a stock. The arbitrage pricing theory apt, which allows multiple sources of systematic risks to be taken into account, performs better than the capm, in all. Jul 22, 2019 arbitrage pricing theory apt is an alternative to the capital asset pricing model capm for explaining returns of assets or portfolios. Factor pricing slide 1223 capm esting fama french 1992. Jun 18, 2019 the capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory can both be used to estimate a theoretical rate of return on an asset.
Capital asset pricing model capm is an arithmetical theory that describes the relationship between risk and return in a balanced market. The capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory. American journal of business education september 2010. May 09, 2019 the capital asset pricing model capm and the arbitrage pricing theory apt help project the expected rate of return relative to risk, but they consider different variables. Capm is more reliable as the probability may go wrong. Capital asset pricing model and arbitrage pricing theory. Arbitrage pricing theory as opposed to capm is a multifactor model suggesting that expected return of an asset cannot be measured accurately by taking into account only one factor, i. Capm or apt choose any one arbitrage pricing theory.
379 63 370 200 345 267 1181 430 559 827 182 419 1007 152 207 570 487 33 384 1470 1503 258 477 199 170 1307 407 623 112 650